| Champion | Won At | Date Won | Date Lost | Reign Duration | |
| Alexander Strider | Zero To Hero | 06/05/05 | 01/07/05 | 56 days | |
| Pierce Lavelle | Solarized | 01/07/05 | 19/08/05 | 49 days | |
| The Educator | The Battle Of Britain | 19/08/05 | 30/08/05 | 11 days | |
| Pierce Lavelle (2) | Fresh! | 30/08/05 | 17/01/06 | 140 days | |
| The Illustrious Face-Eater | Fresh! | 17/01/06 | 01/09/06 | 227 days | |
| The IFE tricked Sasha Volkyeva into sanctioning his crown as "the Transatlantic title", yet there was already a Transatlantic title in the form of the belt. Thus, two Transatlantic championships ran concurrently. | |||||
| Jack Murphy | Bloodlust | 17/02/06 | 24/03/06 | 35 days | |
| Pierce Lavelle (3) | Fresh!special: Huntington Beach | 01/08/06 | 01/09/06 | 31 days | |
| Concurrent with the IFE: Lavelle held the belt; Face-Eater held the crown. | |||||
| Garbage Bag Johnny | Coast To Coast | 01/09/06 | 24/11/06 | 84 days | |
| GBJ recombined the belt and crown by winning both at Coast to Coast, and subsequently welding them together to form the new (extremely heavy) Transatlantic championship belt. | |||||
| AWC was closed between 24 November 2006 and 25 June 2010. All champions during the hiatus are not given Reign Duration statistics since they held the belt without officially sanctioned challenge. | |||||
| Darcy Crisis | Triangles | 24/11/06 | 01/01/08 | ||
| Garbage Bag Johnny (2) | reFresh! | 01/01/08 | |||
| Garbage Bag Johnny defeated Darcy Crisis at the (untelevised) reunion show. | |||||